I'm really tired of singleplayer games honestly. Even if i'm playing on my own the presence of other people really comforts me. I've tried stuff like webfishing which is great but the social aspect is so much larger than the gameplay and i haven't found good people to play it with. Idk man

So, something with people around you and a sense of community, but not necessarily hardcore gameplay, right ?
I can suggest Team Fortress 2, it has gameplay that range from medium to extreme depending on how you want to play, the community is usually goofy and not that bent on winning the round (unless you're playing competitive. Don't do that.)
Overall very fun ! And free, too.
Or you can try Chivalry 2, also pretty awesome and you don't have to have good aim, since it's melee

Ah ! I thought you were looking for a shooter, my bad.

Dude i have something to tell you.

TF2 is a shooter
I have 764 hours in TF2
I suck at shooters

Maybe i'll try mvm someday, i feel like it could be a lot more relaxed and less enraging that casual.